Skip to content

Law Office of Yuri Starikov, LLCLaw Office of Yuri Starikov, LLC

157-11 Rockaway Blvd., Suite 209, Jamaica, NY 11434 | yuri@starikovlaw.com | + 1 (347) 871 2759

  • Law Office of Yuri Starikov, LLC
  • About Us
  • Publications
  • Library
    • Legal Writing
    • New Jersey
      • Criminal Law
      • Vehicle and Traffic Law
    • New York
      • Appellate Practice
      • Consumer Debt
      • Contracts
      • Corporate Law
      • Criminal Law
      • Employment Law
      • Foreclosures
      • Landlord-Tenant
      • Real Estate Law
      • Uncontested Divorce
      • Vehicle and Traffic Law
    • Federal
      • Criminal Law
      • Customs & International Trade Law
      • Employment Law
      • Immigration Law
      • Tax Law
      • Trademark Law
Home > 2020 > January > 10 > Dealing with Naughty Neighbors (Tale of Christmas “Gremlin”)
Published January 10, 2020 by Yuri Starikov

Dealing with Naughty Neighbors (Tale of Christmas “Gremlin”)

GremlinWishing everyone happy and prosperous New Year 2020!  I would like to thank all the folks who subscribed to our YouTube channel.  I received many inquiries about continuation of seminars (and their publications) on topic of U.S. Customs law and preparation for the U.S. Licensed Customs Broker examination.  Because our office assumed substantial litigation responsibilities, we had to take a pause on the seminars.  The pause, although substantial, is a temporary phenomenon, and we hope to jump back into the customs seminar business soon.

In the meantime, sharing of perspectives for dealing with neighbors is a topic of today.  New York City is a crowded place, and living here requires one to deal with all types of individuals who may not necessarily agree with your philosophy.  Sometimes such disagreements result in exchange of unpleasantries and discomfort.  However, disagreements can also result in opportunities.  One such opportunity was presented to me this Monday, January 6, 2020 on the Eve of Russian-Orthodox Christmas.

Upon returning home, I discovered that the Christmas decorations above my apartment building entrance were not working.  Closer examination revealed that the Christmas projector was gone, Christmas garland not lit, wires were cut.  Examination of camera footage revealed that the “Gremlin” culprit responsible for the deed had the same appearance as my neighbor.  This was very surprising, because normally neighbors don’t do this (at least in my experience).  After ringing the doorbell and knocking on the window, I saw my neighbor looking at me through the glass for a second, and then disappearing.  After several attempts, and getting nowhere, I printed out the camera footage showing her act of taking down my Christmas decorations.  The print out had a note asking to explain what happened.  Having received no answer, I thought that this would be a good opportunity to look at the law and see how it is applicable to this incident.  Most importantly, it is also an opportunity to see the difference, if any, between how the law is written and how it is applied.

First and foremost, it is of course New York Penal Law.  Starting point is evaluation of statutes, including NY Pen. Law § 155.25 (Petit larceny), NY Pen. Law § 145.00 (Criminal Mischief in the fourth degree), NY Pen. Law § 140.35 (Possession of burglar’s tools).  It is applied by calling New York City Police Department, and filing of the criminal complaint.  After inviting police officers to review the footage (reproduced below, but in a raw format) and issue a report, the impression was not very optimistic in light of much more serious (in NYPD’s discretion) crimes that are overwhelming the department.  Therefore, a civil side may provide answers.

One possible pointer is whether the Landord can put pressure on a naughty neighbor to return the Christmas decorations (or pay for them).  It turns out that our legislature thought of situations such as these and designed statutory framework of incentives.  On such incentive is N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 231, which holds Landlord liable for tenant’s acts:

The owner of real property, knowingly leasing or giving possession of the same to be used or occupied, wholly or partly, for any unlawful trade, manufacture or business, or knowingly permitting the same to be so used, is liable severally, and also jointly with one or more of the tenants or occupants thereof, for any damage resulting from such unlawful use, occupancy, trade, manufacture or business.

The problem is of course the “knowledge” prong.  So to avail yourself of N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 231, Landlord must be notified.  This implies that after notifying the Landlord, my naughty neighbor needs to do another illegal act, before Landlord can be named as a defendant.

Another statute is Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law § 715, which would allow the victim to step into the shoes of a Landlord of a naughty neighbor, and begin a holdover process.  The statute requires certain condition, which include: (1) neighbor’s apartment be within 200 feet of victim’s apartment, (2) service to landlord, and (3) lack of response from landlord.  New York judiciary is quite explicit that RPAPL § 715 involves “matters of public policy for the protection of the safety and welfare of neighboring tenants and the community.”  RRW Realty Corp. v. Flores, 1999, 179 Misc.2d 757, 686 N.Y.S.2d 278.

Finally, there is a tort action upon tenant herself.  Provided the small amounts involved, the matter will be handled by small claims court, with allegations of conversion and civil theft and trespass.  Depending on the nature of naughtiness, and one’s energies, one can avoid small claims route and opt for preliminary and permanent injunctions under CPLR §§ 6301,6311.

In this video footage, all of criminal acts are allegations and actors are presumed innocent until proven guilty in the court of law.

Share

Previous Post New York City Bar Event on DACA and TPS

Next Post Small Businesses of New York State: Review of Getting Up To $5,100.00 / Person in Federal Funds

Yuri Starikov

Criminal Law Landlord-Tenant Law

CPLR 6301 CPLR 6311 NYPL 140.35 NYPL 145.00 NYPL 155.25 RPAPL 715 RPL 231

Featuring Our Latest Video (Full Video Library at Vimeo.com/StarikovLaw)

https://vimeo.com/491866850?loop=0

Events

CUSTOMS BROKER LICENSE EXAM PREPARATION CLASSES for April 2021 Exam: January 7, 2021-March25, 2021.

Registration is Open at LawCustoms Store. Class details are available at Live Classes Page.

PUBLICATION CATEGORIES

  • Administrative Law
  • Consumer Protection Law
  • Contract Law
  • Corporate Law
  • Criminal Law
  • Employment Law
  • Health Law
  • Immigration Law
  • International Trade Law
  • Landlord-Tenant Law
  • Legal Profession
  • Tax Law
  • Training & Development

TOPICS & DISCUSSIONS

15 NYCRR 122 22 NYCRR 208 Affordable Care Act Antitrust Arbitration Bail CARES Act COVID-19 CPL 1.20 CPL 100.10 CPL 100.25 CPL 100.40 CPL 150.10 CPL 170.30 CPL 170.35 CPL 170.55 CPLR 213 CPLR 317 CPLR 3211 CPLR 3215 CPLR 5015 CPLR 6301 CPLR 6311 Diversion FOIA ICC Termination Act of 1995 Immigration and Nationality Act New Jersey State New York City New York City Human Rights Law New York State NYPL 15.15 NYPL 140.35 NYPL 145.00 NYPL 155.25 RPAPL 715 RPL 231 Rules of Professional Conduct Sentencing U.S. Constitution U.S. Federal UNIDROIT VTL 511 VTL 512 VTL 1807

Law Office of Yuri Starikov, LLC

157-11 Rockaway Blvd., Suite 209, Jamaica, NY 11434 | yuri@starikovlaw.com | + 1 (347) 871 2759

Subscribe to Publications & Newsletters

Loading

Disclaimer, Copyright and Licensing Terms

LEGAL DISCLAIMER
All postings on this website should not be treated as a legal advice. The information may be outdated and may reflect views that are different from the position of government officials or other persons. Certain statements may be construed as "Attorney Advertising." Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

COPYRIGHT
Except as otherwise noted, information on this website was written by Law Office of Yuri Starikov, LLC. The Office retains the copyright to its writings.

LICENSING
UNLESS SPECIFIED OTHERIWISE, you may use Law Office of Yuri Starikov, LLC online publications subject to terms under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Under the license terms, you may use our Office web publications as you see fit, so long as you identify Law Office of Yuri Starikov, LLC as the source.

Creative Commons License

USEFUL LINKS

  • Federal Register
  • FindLaw
  • Google Scholar
  • Laws of New York
  • Public Library of Law
© 2020 Law Office of Yuri Starikov, LLC